Skip to main content
Food Safety

Agri-Food fraud: What does it mean?

EU legislation does not provide a definition of “fraud” in the agri-food chain.

Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/1715 defines a ‘fraud notification’ in iRASFF and thus, indicates the key elements to be considered. In this regard, agri-food fraud is “a non-compliance concerning any suspected intentional action by businesses or individuals, for the purpose of deceiving purchasers and gaining undue advantage therefrom, in violation of the rules referred to in Article 1(2) of Regulation (EU) 2017/625”.

Considering that Article 1(2) extends the scope of official controls to the entire agri-food chain, this definition applies beyond fraud related to food and so also covers other categories of products such as plant health, animal health and feed.

Four key operative criteria are referred to for distinguishing whether a case should be considered a "non-compliance" or "suspicion of fraud" – for that, all four criteria have to be met.

ff_wim-2.jpg

These conditions correspond to the rules currently in place in the Member States to report fraud:

  • Violation of EU rules: A violation of one or more rules laid out in the EU agri-food chain legislation as referred to in Article 1(2) of Regulation (EU) 2017/625.

  • Deception of customers: Some form of deception of the customers/consumers (for example: altered colouring or altered labels, which hide the true quality or, in worse cases, even the nature of a product). Moreover, the deceptive element may also come as a public health risk as some of the real properties of the product are hidden (for example, in the case of undeclared allergens).

  • Undue advantage: the fraudulent act brings some form of direct or indirect economic advantage for the perpetrator.

  • Intention: Verified when a number of factors give strong grounds to show that certain non-compliances are not accidental, such as the intentional substitution of a high quality ingredient with a lower quality one, rather than an accidental contamination due to the production process.

Fraud affects businesses and consumers. The consequences are mainly financial, particularly when the fraud is related to quality. However, these intentional infringements of the EU agri-food chain legislation may hinder the functioning of the EU Single Market and may also constitute a risk to human, animal or plant health, to animal welfare or to the environment. Fraudulent practices can happen at any stage of production, processing and trade and the purchaser that is the victim can be the final consumer as well as a business operator.

Related links